huemorgan2/say-hi
Can a model that only picks from a list learn to talk? JEV types every reply one key at a time. - huemorgan2/say-hi
1 stars · 2 forks
README
say-hi Can a model that only picks from a list learn to talk? Repository: https://github.com/huemorgan2/say-hi
JEV (TypeSafe's jev-1.13.0) isn't a text generator. It's a chooser: you send it a situation (state) and a question with a set of options (criteria), and it picks one, with a confidence and a probability for every option. say-hi tries to get it to talk anyway, by giving it a keyboard. Every reply is typed one key per JEV request: letters, digits, punctuation, space, backspace, return and a SEND key. It's a fun experiment with Jev, and a starting point for simple chatbots with canned responses: replace the keyboard (or the answer list) with your own canned replies, and Jev picks the best one for each message. Run it git clone https://github.com/huemorgan2/say-hi.git cd say-hi npm install cp .env.example .env # then put your TypeSafe key in TYPESAFE_API_KEY npm start # http://localhost:4317 Requires Node 21.7+. The key stays on the server; without it, the page shows a configuration error (there is no fake brain). Every reply has hard caps: 400 keystrokes and $0.50 (JEV_CHAT_MAX_KEYSTROKES, JEV_CHAT_MAX_USD_PER_REPLY). A Stop button aborts the current request. The page shows the chat, an on-screen keyboard that lights up each key Jev presses, and a live time · keys · cost line under each reply. The JEV calls panel on the right has one chip per request. Click a chip to see the exact request sent, the top options with their probabilities, and the raw response. Everything is also appended to logs/YYYY-MM-DD.jsonl (git-ignored; the key is never logged). How a reply is made
Plan: one request, where Jev picks the reply's goal: greet, introduce, answer, repeat, feeling, support, ask, correction, goodbye or chat. Answer: Jev picks the key word of its reply (for a question, the answer itself) from ~10,000 candidates: your words, numbers 0–255, years 1900–2100, and the most frequent English words. A JEV question may list at most 255 options, so this runs as a tournament: groups of 250 asked in parallel, then a final between the group winners. Every round also offers NONE, meaning "I'll type it myself". This step is skipped for greetings, goodbyes and repeats. Typing: one request per key. The state holds the conversation, the goal, the chosen answer word, the reply typed so far, the current word and the last character. Every option shows how the reply will read after that key, plus a hint: for a letter, which real words it leads to; for space or punctuation, whether it finishes a real word; for a digit, which number it builds. Once a word is started, whole-word completions from predictionary are offered as well (word:hello). Keys that only cause loops are not offered (double spaces, retyping a letter just deleted, repeating the previous word, more than 12 words, and so on). The loop ends when Jev presses SEND.
What we learned
Jev knows answers but can't spell its way to them. Letter by letter it answered 3x4 with "8", and "who invented relativity" with word salad. Offered whole answers, it picks 12, 19, 2000, Einstein, and 2 × 10^30 kg for the sun's mass, each at about 100%. A single letter doesn't look like the answer, so the first key is a guess. Once a word is under way it spells perfectly (after inv it chose e-n-t-e-d at 96–99% each). The answer tournament exists because of this. The hints do most of the work. Showing each key's result and the words it leads to took spelling from 70% to about 100%. Plain text beats clever markup. Previews with normal spaces scored better than previews with a visible · for space. Measured on a scripted 18-turn English conversation (npm run eval, score out of 3 for SEND + real words + correct answer): 2.47 → 2.77 across 16 measured iterations. Still weak: open-ended advice (word salad), answers that are neither one word nor a small number (30x50 → "100"), and words outside the vocabulary ("meow").
The cost of saying "hi" Measured with say-hi on 2026-09-30: Jev typed "Hi" in 4 requests (plan, H, i, SEND) using 10,639 input tokens. Each LLM is priced for the same 10,639 input tokens plus a short ~15-token reply.
JEV Claude Opus 5.5 OpenAI GPT-5.6 Sol xAI Grok 4.5
Price per 1M tokens (in / out) $0.042 / free $4 / $20 $4 / $20 $2 / $6
One "hi" $0.00045 $0.0429 $0.0429 $0.0214
1,000 "hi"s $0.45 $42.86 $42.86 $21.37
TypeSafe's published JEV price is $0.042 per million input tokens, and output is free. The JEV token count is the usage the API returned. Opus 5.5 always thinks, which adds output tokens on top of its figure. Prices as of 2026-09-30: Anthropic, OpenAI, xAI. Tests npm test # mocked TypeSafe responses only; no paid calls npm run eval -- <label> # LIVE and PAID: the scripted 18-turn conversation, scored npm run eval writes to logs/eval/ and stops once the total eval spend reaches JEV_EVAL_TOTAL_USD (default $3). Files
File What it does
server.js Local HTTP server (127.0.0.1 only): holds the key, streams each JEV call to the page over SSE, writes logs
jev-typist.js The keyboard, the plan and answer steps, the loop rules and the typing loop
predictor.js Word completions and answer candidates (predictionary + words.txt)
public/index.html Chat window, on-screen keyboard and JEV calls panel
eval/live-eval.mjs The live scored conversation
License AGPL-3.0, because say-hi depends on predictionary, which is AGPL-3.0.